Power Struggle: Rodriguez, Schiano Demonstrate Change in Collegiate Football Coaching Contracts

The dynamic between the coaches of Division I football teams and the universities that employ them is quickly becoming a hot topic.  The ever-increasing popularity of the college game coupled with the vast financial opportunities have thrust coaches into the spotlight.  As players only wear the  colors of their university for only three or four years,  head coaches have become the proverbial faces of their respective collegiate programs.  

The desire of universities for a top-flight coach has perpetuated a system of free agency in the coaching industry.  Perhaps no coach better represents this trend than Michigan’s Rich Rodriguez.

West Virginia v. Rich Rodriguez: Buyout Clause Upheld

Rodriguez was highly successful leading the West Virginia University football program, implementing a quick-strike, spread offense that made the Mountaineers the toast of the Big East and a nationally ranked team.  The success of Rodriguez did not go unnoticed.  The once-mighty Alabama Crimson Tide even attempted to lure Rodriguez to roam the sidelines once patrolled by Bear Bryant.  Rodriguez waffled before signing an extension with West Virginia. 

West Virginia, made fully aware of Rodriguez’s wandering eye during Alabama’s pursuit of the coach, had the foresight to protect itself contractually.  The contract extension between West Virginia and Rodriguez contained a $4 million buyout clause, enforceable should Rodriguez leave the university.  One year after turning down the Alabama job, Rodriguez accepted the head job at the University of Michigan. 

Surprisingly, Rodriguez did not negotiate a reduction of the $4 million payment before departing West Virginia, nor did it appear he had an agreement with Michigan that it would assume the payment.  Rodriguez refused to pay the $4 million, claiming that the university broke certain oral promises it made to him, leading to litigation in federal court.  The case was recently settled - with Rodriguez (perhaps with some contribution from Michigan boosters) paying the entire $4 million to West Virginia.

West Virginia v. Rodriguez could reasonably be read as a shift in power from coaches to the universities.  Although the court was not given the opportunity to decide the case, the fact that the settlement paid West Virginia every penny of the buyout certainly suggests that the court would have found the clause enforceable. 

Rutgers’ Greg Schiano and His Secret Escape Clause

Rutgers head football coach Greg Schiano created a stir, or rather a collective sigh of relief in New Jersey by turning down the Michigan job that Rodriguez ultimately accepted.  Recently, Schiano created another stir when it was reported that he had negotiated a secret side-deal with Rutgers.  The discussion of whether a public university should negotiate a secret deal with one of its coaches is best left to others.  However, the actual terms of the contract are of great interest from a sports law perspective.  One of the provisions of this side deal is that Schiano, whose contract contains a $500,000 buyout (should he leave after the 2009 season), can leave Rutgers without penalty if the university fails to complete its 14,000 seat, $102 million stadium renovation on time:

We wanted to maintain the momentum of the program…We wanted to keep Greg Schiano as our coach…It is a commitment to the coach that the two phases of the expansion of the stadium will be completed by the beginning of the 2009 football season.  -Rutgers University President Richard McCormick

In the Rodriguez case, the coach’s claims that the university broke promises made to him were weak, as the alleged terms were not contained within the four corners of the contract.  (A similar situation arose when June Jones left the University of Hawaii to become the head coach at Southern Methodist University).  Schiano, however, was able to get these terms in writing from Rutgers and can leave without penalty if the terms are not fulfilled.

An escape clause such as Schiano’s may mitigate the power of universities when it comes time to negotiate a buyout clause with a coach.  Also, an escape clause is likely to strengthen an argument that a buyout clause is enforceable, as both parties receive benefits and give up rights under the deal.  Accordingly, a court is unlikely to find such a clause unconscionable. 

In collegiate football, the top schools may not agree to such clauses.  Certain programs – Florida, Michigan, Notre Dame, USC, etc. – possess inherent leverage arising from the universities’ history and success.  Thus, these schools may not need to agree to creative contract terms to attract and retain top coaching talent.  However, schools like Rutgers, that run the risk of losing their coaches to larger programs, may be forced to accept such terms to keep coaching talent, like Schiano, on campus.

Comments

  1. En tant qu etudiant sur ce theme, je me permets de vous feliciter pour la qualite de votre publication et ne manquerai pas de citer votre exemple dans mes prochains rapports:)

  2. Hello, just want to share with you, ne News Network with hourly update trends news, visit News Network

  3. Thanks for this inforamative article. Just one quick question as well, where can I find the theme you have on your website? Cheers mate.

  4. `”, that seems to be a great topic, i really love it -;.

  5. That is very interesting, You’re an excessively skilled blogger. I’ve joined your rss feed and look forward to in the hunt for more of your excellent post. Additionally, I’ve shared your web site in my social networks!- Elegant London Escorts, 65-67 Brewer Street, Floor: 2, London W1F 9UP. Phone: 020 3011 2941

  6. http://www.fiverr.com/users/danzig/gigs/submit-your-rss-feeds-to-around-40-top-directories I will submit your RSS feeds to around 40 top directories for $5

  7. Thanks , I’ve just been searching for information approximately this subject for ages and yours is the greatest I’ve discovered so far. However, what about the bottom line? Are you sure about the supply?

  8. Great website. Lots of useful information here. I am sending it to some friends ans also sharing in delicious. And naturally, thanks to your sweat!

  9. Hi, I’m visit your internet site with my I phone. You have a quite wonderful desgin and awareness article. At property I will add you to my rss reader, didn’t mess that up.|You’ve actually a awareness personal posting design and present beneficial info. The content articles are good to study and you don´t use excellent ads like all the other bloggers.|Quite wonderful desgin of the web page. It’s person and compares for a posts. Don´t give up and make your individual thing!|Hi, at the moment I’m looking with my iphone four new layout ideas and so I have observed your web site. Your design is genuinely quick but also compare it for your posts. I imagine I would use it for my initial draft. Thank you for this idea!|Hi, I’m pay a visit to your web site with my I phone. You possess a extremely excellent desgin and awareness publish. At house I’ll add you to my rss reader, didn’t mess that up.|You’ve got really a curiosity very own posting style and offer good details. The content articles are fine to study and you don´t use many ads like every one of the other bloggers.|Incredibly excellent desgin of your web site. It is person and compares for your posts. Don´t give up and make your own issue!|Thats a actually good post with essential Data. Thanks for your aid.|Thats exact what I have searched for. I imagine with this basics I can get far more details.|Realy fine submit. I’ve observed your web page about google and will visite it regulary.

  10. Thank you for this great article. It contains excellent data which I require. I’ll bookmark your web site by my next check out.

  11. “Advantageously, the post is really the greatest on this valuable topic. I fit in together with your conclusions and will thirstily look forward for your incoming updates.”

  12. fantastic publish,i like

  13. I feel e book bookworm sooner or later are more accepted in every country on the planet.

  14. A few useful info all over your blog,will be back again soon for another great read.

  15. Appreciate it for this fantastic post, I am glad I discovered this website on yahoo.

  16. Great.. but i like that article. We created this website to all of you fans of tattoos for inspiration in making a tattoo.

  17. Hello folks, We found your site and I to appoint its a great source where nice people discuss, and I want to congratulate You are great. Maintain the wonderful job.

  18. Hello my family member! I wish to say that this post is amazing, great written and include almost all vital infos. I would like to see more posts like this.

  19. Its like you read my mind! You seem to grasp a lot about this, such as you wrote the e book in it or something. I think that you simply can do with some % to force the message home a bit, but other than that, that is magnificent blog. A great read. I will definitely be back.

  20. I read this article fully regarding the difference of newest and earlier technologies, it’s remarkable article.

  21. It’s appropriate time to have plans for the future and it’s time to be happy. I’ve read this submit and if I could I want to propose you couple of interesting items or tips. Maybe you may write up coming articles talking about this article. I want to read more aspects of it!

Trackbacks

  1. [...] a new contract, which includes a $1.5 buyout clause should he leave UConn after this season.  Rich Rodriguez left West Virginia for Michigan despite a whopping $4 million buyout clause.  Will another post-season bowl appearance [...]

  2. [...] the complexity of coaching contracts, including buyout and termination clauses, the dollars involved with sponsorship deals, media deals and the watchful eye of the NCAA, hiring [...]

  3. [...] cases of Nick Saban and Rich Rodriguez, whose hollow denials of interest in other coaching jobs, shortly before bolting for those very [...]

  4. [...] Contract: Expectations Unfulfilled The power struggle between college football coaches and the universities for which they work, has taken some [...]

  5. [...] renovation of the football stadium.  The renovation is so crucial to the football, that coach Greg Schiano had a secret clause in his contract allowing him to leave the school should the renovation not be completed on time.   This secret [...]

  6. [...] of college coaching.  The previously accepted norms in college coaching are shifting, as shown by West Virginia v. Rodriguez, the BC-Jagodzinski situation, and Marist v. [...]

  7. [...] cases of Nick Saban and Rich Rodriguez, whose hollow denials of interest in other coaching jobs, shortly before bolting for those very [...]

  8. [...] invicta+signature+diver+mechanical+stainless+steel+mens+watch+0123 invictafm jacques cartier panerai panerai 111 panerai 1950 panerai 312 panerai 372 panerai 390 panerai armband Click here to cancel reply. [...]

  9. Power Struggle: Rodriguez, Schiano Demonstrate Change in Collegiate Football Coaching Contracts – CONNECTICUT SPORTS LAW…

    Thank you for any other informative blog. Where else may just I am getting that kind of info written in such a perfect way? I have a project that I am simply now running on, and I have been at the glance out for such information….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 942 other followers

%d bloggers like this: